I’ve had my previous post about emotional eating kind of running around in my head lately. I still believe what I wrote about emotional eating, but I’ve been trying to reconcile the fact that I do believe my obesity was driven primarily by physiological causes to the fact that there is obviously some psychological component to my relationship with food and to the fact that so many seem to believe their weight issues are emotionally driven.
I’m the first to admit that I will reach for food if I’m upset. And I’m also the first to admit that my relationship with food is not an easy one. I don’t deal with hunger or deprivation well, I get antsy and uptight if I can’t eat when I feel I need to. I need more control over my food than many others do. So I don’t pretend that my food and weight issues have no psychological effect on me.
As I watched “The Biggest Loser: Families” on TV last night, I got to thinking about how, for many of the contestants, there is definitely a big emotional or psychological component in their weight loss journey. I’ve watched every year of this series since its inception, and have observed how, especially for the women, losing weight often becomes a time where the contestants learn to value themselves, find self-acceptance and self-love.
How to reconcile it all? I’m kind of thinking out loud here, but I have some ideas that make a little sense to me.
I do stand by my original premise. I hate the term emotional eating and the insistance that it is behind all obesity and making it sound like a deep-rooted psychological disorder. I really feel it diminishes the reality of what is happening and shames us for having confusing responses around food when what we really need is solutions, tools and self-acceptance. I hate the underlying assumption that the obese are of poor moral character because we use food as a coping mechanism sometimes. Everyone uses a coping mechanism sometimes, the fact that ours is food is less harmful than some coping mechanisms, though admittedly, not as healthy as others.
But, maybe I was wrong in assuming the two aren’t connected for many people.
Maybe the degree to which there is a psychological component to our obesity differs from person to person. In me, I think it’s small, as I said before. But maybe that’s because I did therapy for years and dealt with much of the very real life and esteem issues I had in my younger years. If I had never dealt with those issues previously, then started losing weight, would the weight loss have been a catalyst for emotional change? Would I have then sought to solve some of those life issues and become convinced that the two (weight and emotion) were two halves of the same coin?
Maybe, it’s just that there are life issues that need to be resolved that aren’t necessarily tied to weight, but when we make huge shifts in our lives, like losing weight, it throws off our equillibrium and we are forced to deal with life issues that were lying quietly before. We are challenging the status quo with regard to our physical health, and so we inadvertantly challenge the status quo of our mental health. It seems like the two are irrevocably intertwined, and maybe it’s easier to deal with them as one issue, but perhaps they are two seperate issues, either one of which could have been dealt with without the others at a different time or place in our lives.
And then, for others, maybe the two are irrevocably linked, one unsolveable without solving the other? Particularly in cases of abuse, I can see this as possibly being true, where people may have cloaked themselves in weight in an effort to protect themselves from further abuse. Certainly we see people act out in response to life’s traumas in many ways, why can’t obesity be one of them?
I have noticed that people tend to assume that what is true for them is necessarily true for others. I guess I made the same mistake in that earlier blog post, assuming that because my obesity was mostly physiological, that it must be that way for others. Maybe I’m just in the minority of people that have dealt with their emotional issues and obesity issues seperately. Could the strong current belief that emotional issues must be at the heart of obesity stem from the fact that the majority of people who have lost weight have just found they had to deal with emotional issues (whether they were truly connected or not) at the same time?
No answers, just more questions.